supervised vs unsupervised

 



Supervised vs. Unsupervised Learning in CFD Modeling of Pedestrian Wind Comfort

StepSupervised Learning Approach (Predicting Pedestrian Wind Comfort)Unsupervised Learning Approach (Clustering Wind Comfort Zones)
Problem DefinitionPredict pedestrian wind comfort levels based on CFD simulation data. <br> - Key Parameters: wind speed, direction, building geometry, comfort level.Cluster pedestrian zones based on wind comfort characteristics without predefined labels. <br> - Key Parameters: wind speed, direction, building geometry.
Data CollectionCollect CFD simulation data and corresponding comfort levels through measurements or predefined scales.Gather CFD simulation data for pedestrian zones, including wind speed, direction, and building geometry.
Data Preprocessing- Clean data: Remove outliers/errors. <br> - Feature Engineering: Create/modify features. <br> - Split data into training and testing sets.- Clean data: Remove outliers/errors. <br> - Standardize/Normalize data to ensure uniform scale and consistency.
Model Selection and TrainingChoose and train a Random Forest Regression model on the training dataset to predict comfort levels.Apply K-Means Clustering to group pedestrian zones based on wind comfort characteristics. <br> Determine optimal number of clusters using the elbow method.
Model Evaluation and Optimization- Evaluate using metrics like MSE/MAE. <br> - Optimize by tuning hyperparameters and validating with cross-validation.- Analyze clusters to understand distinct comfort regimes. <br> - Label clusters based on characteristics (e.g., high, moderate, low comfort).
Prediction and DeploymentUse the trained model to predict pedestrian comfort levels in new CFD simulations. <br> Deploy for real-time predictions in urban planning.- Visualize clusters on a map/chart to identify comfort zones. <br> - Use color coding to represent different clusters.
Results ReportingVisualize predicted vs. actual comfort levels to assess accuracy. <br> Generate reports to communicate findings to stakeholders.Provide recommendations for urban design improvements based on comfort zones. <br> Suggest changes to building geometries or pathways to enhance comfort.